Home > Money > Question
Need Expert Advice?Our Gurus Can Help
Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |8439 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 24, 2024

Ramalingam Kalirajan has over 23 years of experience in mutual funds and financial planning.
He has an MBA in finance from the University of Madras and is a certified financial planner.
He is the director and chief financial planner at Holistic Investment, a Chennai-based firm that offers financial planning and wealth management advice.... more
Bhogu Question by Bhogu on May 20, 2024Hindi
Listen
Money

Sir - Is having MFs in Demat form advantageous rather than in physical possession? I shall be grateful for your advice.

Ans: Demat vs. Physical Mutual Funds: Which is Better?
Let's delve into the advantages and disadvantages of holding Mutual Funds (MFs) in Demat form versus physical possession to help you make an informed decision.

Understanding Demat Accounts
Demat Account Advantages
Convenience: Demat accounts offer a single platform to hold various financial securities, including stocks, bonds, and mutual funds.
Electronic Transactions: Allows for easy buying, selling, and transferring of mutual fund units, eliminating paperwork and manual processes.
Demat Account Disadvantages
Annual Charges: Demat accounts typically incur annual maintenance charges, adding to the overall cost of holding investments.
Transaction Charges: Each transaction (buying, selling, or transferring units) attracts transaction charges, increasing the cost further.
Opting for Physical Mutual Funds
Advantages of Physical Mutual Funds
No Annual Charges: Unlike Demat accounts, physical mutual funds do not entail annual maintenance charges, reducing overall expenses.
No Transaction Charges: Physical mutual funds eliminate transaction charges associated with buying, selling, or transferring units.
Conclusion: Which Option to Choose?
Given the disadvantages associated with Demat accounts for holding mutual funds, opting for physical possession seems more advantageous in the long run.

Recommendation
Considerations for Holding Physical Mutual Funds
Convenience: Physical mutual funds offer ease of ownership without the hassle of account maintenance charges or transaction fees.
Cost-Efficiency: By avoiding annual charges and transaction fees, you can minimize expenses and maximize returns on your investments.
Simplicity: Holding physical mutual funds simplifies your investment portfolio management and reduces the administrative burden.
Making an Informed Decision
While Demat accounts offer convenience and electronic access to financial securities, the associated costs may outweigh the benefits, especially for mutual fund investors.

Seek Professional Advice
Consult with a Certified Financial Planner (CFP) to assess your individual circumstances, risk tolerance, and investment objectives. A CFP can provide personalized guidance and recommend the most suitable investment approach aligned with your financial goals.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in
Asked on - May 24, 2024 | Answered on May 24, 2024
Listen
Dear Sir, Many thanks for your kind clarification. With warm regards Dr Bhogu CM
Ans: You're welcome! If you have any more questions or need further assistance, feel free to ask. Best wishes on your financial journey!

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in
DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information to be as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision.
Money

You may like to see similar questions and answers below

Latest Questions
Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |8439 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 15, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - May 06, 2025
Money
Hi Sir, I am confused between HDFC FMP & C2i without tax and Regular Mutual Funds plan with tax deduction. HDFC FMP & C2i is (Fixed Maturity Plan and Click to Invest including insurance of 70 lacs ) plan, per year plan is to pay 7.5 lacs for every 5 years which will gain upto 1.20 Cr tax free amount under section 10D in 15 years, is this plan good to invest or investing those money in regular way into Mutual Funds will be good? I understand it will be taxable if I invest in MF however gain will be more compared to this policy? FYI I already have term insurance since last 5 years am paying for it. am not sure what to do? can you please advice me correctly. Many Thanks PT
Ans: You have asked a very important question.

It is good that you are comparing different products before investing.

You are thinking long-term and planning in advance. That is a great habit.

Let us now look at the facts from all angles.

You mentioned HDFC FMP and C2i insurance. Let’s compare these with mutual funds clearly.

Let’s go step by step.

Understanding the Structure of Insurance-Linked Investment Plans
These insurance investment plans combine life insurance with investment.

They may promise tax-free maturity under Section 10(10D).

These plans also usually have guaranteed maturity values or bonus additions.

But the returns are fixed and capped. They mostly fall between 5% to 6%.

There is very low liquidity. You cannot exit before 5 years easily.

If you surrender early, penalties are very high.

You already have a term insurance. So, life cover in these plans is not needed.

Paying Rs. 7.5 lakhs per year for 5 years is a huge commitment.

Once you start, you must continue for full 5 years, else you lose benefits.

These policies are marketed as safe and tax-free.

But inflation can easily beat these kinds of returns over long term.

Even if maturity is tax-free, low growth means less real wealth in hand.

Evaluating Mutual Fund Investment Option (With Tax Impact)
Mutual funds, especially equity-oriented, are linked to the market.

They are not guaranteed. But historically they gave better returns over 10-15 years.

Even after tax, mutual funds can give you more real returns than insurance plans.

The new tax rule says LTCG above Rs. 1.25 lakhs is taxed at 12.5%.

Even then, if a mutual fund gives 11% to 13% CAGR, net returns are much better.

You also get liquidity in mutual funds. You can stop, start or withdraw any time.

You can also step up the SIP amount based on your income.

No lock-in, no surrender charges, and no hidden costs.

You already have term insurance. That gives you pure life cover at low cost.

Mutual funds are only for investment. No mixing of life cover and wealth building.

When life cover and investment are separated, both work efficiently.

Comparing C2i + FMP Plan with Mutual Funds
In C2i plan, you will invest total Rs. 37.5 lakhs (7.5 lakhs x 5 years).

You are promised maturity of around Rs. 1.20 crores after 15 years.

This is like 6% return yearly, assuming tax-free payout.

In mutual funds, even if you invest the same Rs. 7.5 lakhs/year for 5 years,

And you stop fresh investment after 5 years, but stay invested till 15 years,

You can expect Rs. 1.80 crore or even more, depending on performance.

Even after tax, net wealth is much higher than insurance plans.

The flexibility and higher wealth creation makes mutual funds the better option.

Do not just look at tax-free maturity. Look at total wealth creation also.

Insurance is not meant to build wealth. Its only role is to protect life.

You already have term cover. So no extra cover is needed.

Your insurance should protect your family, not your investment goals.

Tax Confusion Should Not Cloud Long-Term Returns
Many people choose insurance plans just to avoid tax.

But they ignore the very low returns of these plans.

A mutual fund taxed at 12.5% can still beat insurance maturity.

For example, if you gain Rs. 10 lakhs in MF, tax is Rs. 1.25 lakh only.

But the remaining Rs. 8.75 lakhs is still more than what insurance plans give.

Long term compounding in mutual funds creates much more wealth.

Tax saving should never be the only reason for investment.

A Certified Financial Planner will always prioritise post-tax, real returns.

That helps you achieve your goals without compromise.

Key Gaps in Insurance-Linked Plans for Long-Term Wealth
Liquidity is poor. Your money is locked.

Returns are low. Real wealth does not grow fast.

Cannot stop premiums mid-way. You lose if you do.

Surrender charges are heavy.

Product structure is complex. Not fully transparent.

Sales people pitch it as tax-free, but ignore inflation impact.

No flexibility to change based on goals.

Policy benefits may not match future needs.

It is one-size-fits-all plan. No customisation is possible.

Why Mutual Funds Remain Most Efficient and Flexible
You can build a portfolio of large cap, mid cap, small cap and multi-cap.

You can change funds if performance drops.

You can pause SIP or withdraw if needed.

You can invest regularly, lumpsum or both.

You can align investments with your goals like retirement, child education, etc.

You can start with lower amount and increase later.

You can also reduce risk slowly as you get older.

Goal-based planning is possible only with mutual funds.

You can track performance any time online.

Regular funds through Certified Financial Planner give personalised service also.

Why Direct Funds Are Not Recommended
Many investors try to save commission by going direct.

But they miss out on review, correction, and expert help.

Wrong fund selection can hurt your goal badly.

Regular funds via Certified Financial Planner ensure you get continuous guidance.

Emotional decisions can ruin returns. Regular plan helps avoid this.

Review, rebalancing and advice is more important than small saving in cost.

Direct fund cost saving is small. But loss due to wrong move can be big.

Certified Financial Planner will guide you in every stage.

That service adds much more value than the small cost of regular funds.

Insurance Policies Like C2i Are Not Designed for Wealth Creation
Their focus is on death benefit, not high returns.

They mix investment with insurance. That reduces both benefits.

The cost structure is complex and opaque.

Once you invest, you lose control for many years.

Exit before maturity brings penalties.

You are forced to stay even if performance is poor.

Sales pitch focuses on tax saving and maturity amount.

But rarely show comparison with mutual funds.

Your long-term financial goals need better growth and flexibility.

What You Should Do
Continue your existing term insurance policy. That is important.

Avoid any new insurance-linked investment. It adds burden, not benefit.

Start or increase investment in mutual funds instead.

Use a mix of multicap, midcap and small cap for long term.

Do goal-based planning – for retirement, child education and emergencies.

Avoid being trapped by tax-free maturity or fixed return offers.

Always ask – is this helping my goal? Or just giving peace of mind?

Tax can be managed. But loss in wealth due to low returns can’t be recovered.

Invest with flexibility, liquidity and guidance.

Final Insights
Your instincts are correct. Mutual funds have more long-term wealth potential.

Do not mix investment and insurance. Keep them separate always.

C2i and FMP look attractive now. But they limit future opportunities.

Tax-free is good. But only when returns are also strong.

Mutual funds, with help from Certified Financial Planner, give clarity and control.

Flexibility, better returns and goal-based investing always win in the long run.

Make your money work harder for your child’s future and your retirement.

Avoid locking large money in rigid, fixed return products.

Mutual funds give you the power to grow, adapt and win financially.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in

https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |8439 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 15, 2025

Money
Sir i am 44 and i have following MF as SIP..15k in Nippon India Small Cap, 5k in Nippon India Multi Cap, 2k in 6 funds namely., Mirae Asset Mid Cap, Axis MF Bluechip, Kotak MF Emerging, Quant Large & Mid Cap, Motilal Mid Cap, SBI MF Contra. Are these right way of distribution of funds or is there any correction required? Other than these i do have few savings plan like Kotak Premium Endownment, Tata AIA, ICICI Pru Future. Amongst these 2 savings plan tenure are going to be completed, so is it a good idea to start new savings plan or invest that amt too in MF? Also where to reinvest the amt that would be matured shortly from these savings plan? Hope these investments will help to lead a decent retirement life after 60...
Ans: You are doing well by taking active steps. At age 44, building a structured and disciplined portfolio is very important. You already have good habits in place.

Let’s look at your current mutual funds and savings plans carefully.

We will also explore the better way forward with complete clarity.

Review of Current SIP Mutual Fund Portfolio
You invest Rs.15,000 in a small-cap fund. That is a very high amount.

Small-cap funds are very volatile. Not good to have high allocation.

You also invest Rs.5,000 in a multi-cap fund. That is a good choice.

You further invest Rs.2,000 each in six other funds.

Those include large-cap, mid-cap, contra, and other categories.

This spread looks like too many funds with small amounts.

Investing Rs.2,000 in multiple funds creates confusion and overlap.

It becomes difficult to monitor and analyse them every year.

Some of these categories may behave similarly.

You need to consolidate your mutual funds to 4–5 only.

Keep funds from different categories – not overlapping ones.

One large-cap, one flexi-cap or multi-cap, one mid-cap, and one small-cap are enough.

This reduces clutter and helps with proper rebalancing.

Always prefer actively managed funds over index funds.

Index funds just copy the market. No expert is managing the risk.

Actively managed funds have potential to beat market returns with less downside.

Also avoid direct mutual funds. They don’t give guidance or yearly reviews.

Use regular plans through Certified Financial Planner (CFP).

You get full support and personalised rebalancing guidance.

Current Allocation Needs Balancing
Rs.15,000 to small-cap is risky. Reduce it to Rs.5,000.

Mid-cap and large & mid-cap categories are already present.

Avoid putting Rs.2,000 in too many similar funds.

Instead, choose one good mid-cap fund and invest Rs.5,000 in it.

Keep Rs.5,000 in a large-cap or contra fund.

Another Rs.5,000 can go into a multi-cap or flexi-cap fund.

Keep your small-cap allocation not more than 20% of total equity.

Small-cap works well only over very long term and high risk tolerance.

Consolidation makes it easier to review and rebalance each year.

Assessment of Traditional Savings Plans
You have 3 savings plans from insurance companies.

Two plans are about to mature.

These include endowment and future guaranteed type plans.

These plans usually give very low returns. Mostly around 4–5%.

You can check the maturity value now and plan reinvestment.

These plans combine insurance with investment. That is never efficient.

Mixing protection and returns reduces both benefits.

Avoid taking new savings plans again.

Start investing in mutual funds instead.

Mutual funds give better flexibility, liquidity, and returns.

For protection, take pure term insurance only.

It gives high cover at low premium. No investment benefit is needed here.

What to Do With the Maturing Amount From Policies
The maturity proceeds should be reinvested based on your goals.

Don’t use that money for new insurance plans or endowment.

You can use the maturity amount for either:

Building a retirement corpus

Your child’s higher education

A specific life goal like business or health buffer

Park the amount first in liquid or ultra-short debt funds.

Then start an STP (Systematic Transfer Plan) into mutual funds.

This avoids sudden lump sum investment into equity.

It reduces timing risk and improves investment safety.

Choose 60% in equity funds and 40% in debt mutual funds.

Do this only after consulting a Certified Financial Planner.

Asset allocation is the real key, not product selection.

Protection Planning – Are You Adequately Insured?
You have mentioned insurance policies but not term cover.

Please ensure you have pure term insurance with high sum assured.

Minimum cover should be 15 times your annual income.

This is needed to protect your family’s future.

Avoid mixing savings with protection ever again.

Also review your medical insurance cover for your family.

At least Rs.10 lakh cover is needed for a family of three or four.

You can consider super top-up if cost is high.

Building Retirement Corpus – Planning for Life After 60
You are 44 now. So 16 years are left for retirement.

A well-managed mutual fund portfolio can build a large corpus in this time.

Continue SIPs regularly. Increase amount when income grows.

Review portfolio every year with a CFP. Rebalance it based on market and goals.

Gradually shift part of equity to debt in your last 4 years before retirement.

That helps protect your retirement capital from sudden market fall.

After retirement, don’t use FDs for income. Use mutual fund SWP.

It gives monthly income with growth and tax efficiency.

Also gives better liquidity and control than pensions or annuities.

Start goal-based investing for your retirement, not random SIPs.

That brings clarity and peace of mind.

How to Move Forward With Confidence
First, consolidate your mutual fund SIPs to 4 or 5 only.

Maintain a healthy mix of large-cap, mid-cap, multi-cap, and small-cap.

Reduce small-cap exposure to less than 20% of total equity.

Avoid all index funds. They don’t have active risk management.

Stop buying savings-cum-insurance plans. Shift to pure investments.

Reinvest maturing amounts into mutual funds through STP route.

Keep your life and health insurance separate from your investments.

Start investing for retirement with clear targets and asset mix.

Use only regular mutual funds via Certified Financial Planner.

Get proper guidance, yearly reviews, and personalised strategy.

That brings discipline and long-term clarity to your journey.

Mutual funds offer growth, liquidity, flexibility, and better tax control.

Finally
Your investment journey has started in the right direction.

But it needs cleaning and realignment now.

You are just 16 years away from retirement.

The right choices now will give you a peaceful retirement.

Avoid insurance plans as investments.

Focus only on mutual funds with proper asset allocation.

Reinvest maturity proceeds wisely with professional help.

Create goal-specific portfolios. Don’t spread money without a reason.

Protect your family with pure insurance, not savings plans.

Keep reviewing and improving every year.

A Certified Financial Planner can give you a full 360-degree plan.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in

https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |8439 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 15, 2025

Money
Sir, I have loan liabilities of 17.36 Lakhs ( 2.32 Lakhs personal Loan and 15.04 Lakhs Jewel mortgage loan) and having the cash reserve of 12 Lakhs which i am using for trading in stock market. What will be the best option for me whether to close the loan with reserved cash or continuing with trading to get the profit which is used to pay the interest charges of loan amount.
Ans: Managing loans while investing or trading requires careful evaluation.

Understanding Your Current Situation
You have total loans of Rs. 17.36 lakhs: Rs. 2.32 lakhs personal loan, Rs. 15.04 lakhs jewel mortgage loan.

You have Rs. 12 lakhs cash reserve invested in stock market trading.

Your trading profits are used to pay loan interest charges.

Your question: whether to use cash to close loans or continue trading to cover interest.

Both choices have pros and cons. Let’s analyse carefully.

Loan Interest and Impact on Finances
Personal loans usually have high interest rates, often 12%-18% per annum.

Jewel mortgage loans have comparatively lower interest, but still costly.

Interest costs reduce your disposable income monthly.

High interest drains your financial power over time.

Reducing or clearing high-interest loans improves cash flow.

Loan principal repayment reduces interest outgo in future.

Evaluating Using Cash to Close Loans
Using Rs. 12 lakhs cash to partly or fully repay loans cuts interest burden.

Personal loan of Rs. 2.32 lakhs can be fully closed immediately.

Rs. 9.68 lakhs can be used to reduce jewel loan principal.

Lower loans mean lower monthly interest payments.

Improves your financial stability and reduces stress.

You lose the cash reserve invested in trading.

No guarantee stock market trading profits will exceed loan interest.

Trading is risky; market may turn against you anytime.

Using cash to pay loans is a safe, risk-free return equal to interest saved.

Evaluating Continuing Trading to Pay Interest
Trading profits are uncertain and risky.

You may earn higher returns than loan interest sometimes.

But losses can increase your burden.

Emotional stress increases when market moves against you.

Trading requires active time, skill, and discipline.

You risk losing capital which is needed to pay loan interest.

Interest on loans continues to accumulate if you don’t reduce principal.

Other Important Points to Consider
Emergency fund: After loan repayment, maintain 3-6 months expenses as cash reserve.

Trading capital: You need some capital for trading but not at the cost of high interest loans.

Loan prepayment penalties: Check if any charges apply.

Alternative income: Can you generate stable income apart from trading?

Risk tolerance: Are you comfortable risking your cash for trading profits?

Psychological impact: High debt plus trading risk can cause stress.

Recommended Approach
First, repay personal loan fully from cash reserve.

Use remaining cash to reduce jewel mortgage loan principal.

This lowers your interest burden significantly.

Keep at least 3 months of living expenses as emergency fund.

Continue trading with smaller capital only if comfortable and disciplined.

Avoid using emergency or loan repayment money for trading.

Focus on stable, low-risk investment avenues for surplus cash.

Once loans reduce, your financial position strengthens.

You can invest more consistently without high interest dragging you down.

Final Insights
Clearing high-interest personal loan first is a priority.

Reducing jewel loan principal lowers interest cost and stress.

Trading profits are uncertain and cannot replace guaranteed loan savings.

Using cash to reduce debt is safer than hoping for market profits.

Maintain emergency fund for financial stability.

Trade only with surplus money after debt control.

This balanced approach strengthens your financial future.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |8439 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 15, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Apr 30, 2025
Money
I am 46 years old male, working in a private company. I have 12 lakh in PPF, 14.2 lakh in NPS, 35 lakh in FD, 1.05 Cr in Stocks/Mutual funds and Unlisted stocks. My EPF stands at 58.4 lakh, ULIP (paused) and a LIC Bima gold policy (2 lakh SA and will mature in 2026) stands at 7.5 lakh. Current in hand salary is 3.75 lakh and out of that 32000 I invest in NPS every month from employer contribution. My current SIP is around 1.8 lakh per month, I also have a retirement plan from Bajaj for which I pay 40K every month. I have a 10 lakh base policy for medical insurance for myself and family of my wife and a 8 year old kid. Recently i lost my job and from July onwards I might not have a salary though other interviews are ongoing. I will have approximately 60 lakh liquid money soon which I can invest in a 60% equity and 40% debt kind of a mix. I do not have any loan and stay at my own house apart from another house in a metro city. My current expense is around 1 lakh per month. My MF portfolio has Parag parikh Flexi cap, Motilal oswal large & mid cap, ICICI Pru multi-asset and UTI Multi-Asset, Canara Robecco and Axis Large cap, Quant Active and Small Cap, HDFC Balanced Advantage, Tata business cycle fund, Kotak Equity Arbitrage fund (4 lakh lumpsum and a STP initiated from here) etc. Please help me in creating a plan to overcome the difficult time which is going to come and also for long term. I plan to work for another 14-15 years. Thanks in advance.
Ans: You have made great progress in your financial life. At 46, your discipline, planning, and asset creation show clear maturity. Your concern now is valid. Job loss can shake confidence, but you are well-prepared.

Let’s take a full-circle view of your situation and create a solid plan.

Assessment of Current Financial Strength
You have a strong foundation in almost every major financial area.

Rs.12 lakh in PPF ensures safe, long-term, tax-free returns.

Rs.14.2 lakh in NPS gives additional retirement security.

Rs.35 lakh in FDs ensures liquidity and capital safety.

Rs.1.05 crore in Mutual Funds and Stocks is a strong growth engine.

Rs.58.4 lakh in EPF gives stable long-term corpus.

A small LIC policy of Rs.7.5 lakh can be surrendered and reinvested.

You also have a ULIP which is paused. This should also be exited.

You have two houses, one is self-occupied, the other can be monetised.

SIP of Rs.1.8 lakh per month is excellent. But needs review now.

A Bajaj Retirement plan of Rs.40,000 per month is heavy and not needed.

Your monthly expenses are Rs.1 lakh, which is well controlled.

Rs.60 lakh liquidity soon gives breathing room in this phase.

No loans. That gives extra peace of mind and cash flow safety.

Medical cover of Rs.10 lakh for family is good and comforting.

Immediate Plan to Manage Job Transition Smoothly
First, secure at least 18 months of expenses as a reserve.

That means Rs.18 lakh should be parked in liquid instruments.

Keep this in ultra-short or low-duration debt mutual funds.

FDs are not tax-efficient and give less flexibility.

Reduce monthly SIPs now. Don’t stop, but reduce to Rs.50,000.

Pause Bajaj retirement policy. Or consider exiting if surrender is possible.

Exit from ULIP and LIC policy. ULIPs give poor returns and lack flexibility.

Reinvest surrender value in mutual funds through Certified Financial Planner.

Avoid investing fresh lump sum into equity right now.

Wait for job clarity before deploying extra funds in equity.

You can keep balance from Rs.60 lakh in mix of debt and hybrid funds.

Avoid direct equity unless guided by a professional. Focus on mutual funds.

Handling Mutual Fund Portfolio – Too Many Funds, Time to Consolidate
You hold many mutual funds across types.

This can create overlap and confuse asset allocation.

Limit to 6–7 funds, well diversified across market caps and styles.

Avoid overlapping categories like too many multi-asset and flexi-cap funds.

Review fund performance yearly with a Certified Financial Planner.

Avoid direct mutual funds. They don’t give support in times like this.

Regular plans through a CFP give strategy, rebalancing, and emotional control.

Avoid index funds. They follow market blindly. No downside protection.

Active funds handle corrections better and capture good opportunities.

Using Rs.60 Lakh – Safe Strategy Until Job Resumes
From Rs.60 lakh, first keep aside Rs.18 lakh for emergency.

Use remaining Rs.42 lakh like this:

Rs.15 lakh in medium duration debt mutual funds.

Rs.10 lakh in equity hybrid funds.

Rs.17 lakh in staggered STP from arbitrage or liquid funds to equity funds.

Use Systematic Transfer Plan (STP) for equity entry over 12–18 months.

Review job status after 6 months. Increase equity if situation is stable.

Re-start paused SIPs only after income resumes.

Managing Expenses – Important but Often Ignored
Monthly expense of Rs.1 lakh is well within control.

Review optional spends like entertainment, travel, or luxury.

Prioritise health, education, and essentials during this phase.

Use credit card smartly, but don’t roll over balance.

Monitor family needs without panic. Children adapt better than we think.

Bajaj Retirement Plan – Evaluate Carefully
Monthly Rs.40,000 is heavy for one policy.

These plans often give poor return with high charges.

Check surrender value and lock-in period.

If surrender is allowed now, exit and reinvest via mutual funds.

You will gain better control and flexibility.

LIC Bima Gold and ULIP – Exit Now
LIC maturity is small and far. Also gives poor return.

ULIP being paused is already not helpful.

Both are not growth-oriented and have low liquidity.

Surrender both and reinvest through mutual funds with CFP support.

Insurance and investment should not be mixed.

Insurance Cover – Review for Adequacy
You have Rs.10 lakh family medical cover. That is good.

Ensure it covers hospitalisation, daycare, and critical illness too.

Review base sum assured. Consider super top-up if possible.

You have not mentioned life insurance cover.

Ensure you have pure term insurance for at least 15 times annual expenses.

Investment-linked policies are not useful now.

Long-Term Retirement Strategy – 14 Years to Prepare
With no loan, you are already ahead in retirement planning.

EPF, NPS, mutual funds, and PPF give diversified retirement sources.

Keep building NPS through employer contribution.

Don’t invest extra in NPS. Lock-in till 60 and annuity rules reduce liquidity.

Rebalance your mutual fund portfolio yearly.

Allocate 60% in equity, 40% in debt as you said.

Gradually move to low volatility, income-oriented funds in last 5 years.

Don’t depend on property rental for retirement income.

Real estate is illiquid and has uncertain rental flow.

Use mutual fund SWP (Systematic Withdrawal Plan) for monthly income post-retirement.

Your Child’s Future – Needs a Separate Plan
Your child is 8 years old. You have around 10–12 years.

Don’t mix her education corpus with your retirement fund.

Start a separate SIP or portfolio for her higher education.

Avoid child ULIPs or endowment policies. Returns are poor and inflexible.

Use mutual funds with long-term goals. Review performance every year.

Equity allocation must be higher in early years.

Reduce risk 3–4 years before goal.

Final Insights
You are already in a strong financial position.

Your savings habit, asset creation, and awareness are truly good.

Job loss is temporary. Your cushion is strong enough to manage.

Don’t panic. Focus on liquidity, not return, for next 6–12 months.

Trim heavy SIPs, pause large commitments like Bajaj plan.

Avoid property investments or new loans now.

Use Certified Financial Planner to simplify and restructure your portfolio.

Stick to active, regular mutual funds for growth and stability.

Your family, child’s future, and your own retirement are well on track.

With right actions now, the next 14–15 years can be very productive.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in

https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |8439 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 15, 2025

Money
I have 10 L lump sum. I want to park it and then do STP. I have two debt funds Nippon liquid and Axis Short term fund, which one will be better to park for stp? How much time should be given to move this to equity by STP. I have Nippon and ICICI large cap, hdfc mid cap,Nippon multi cap and hdfc hybrid equity. Which would be better and how much stp every month? Or do I need to open one more fund for STP? Please guide me for horizon of 6 years
Ans: You have a clear plan of using a lump sum parked in debt funds, then moving gradually to equity via STP for a 6-year horizon. Let me provide a thorough 360-degree assessment and guidance from a Certified Financial Planner perspective.

Parking Lump Sum: Choosing Between Debt Funds
You mentioned Nippon Liquid Fund and Axis Short Term Fund to park your Rs. 10 lakh lump sum.

Liquid funds like Nippon Liquid invest mostly in overnight and very short maturity papers.

Short term funds like Axis Short Term hold instruments with slightly longer maturity, usually 1-3 years.

Liquid funds generally give better liquidity and lower interest rate risk.

Short term funds carry slightly higher credit risk and moderate interest rate risk.

For a 6-year horizon with STP, safety and liquidity matter at the start.

Nippon Liquid Fund is more stable in value, less volatile in interest rates.

Axis Short Term Fund may offer slightly higher returns but can have NAV fluctuations.

Since you want to do STP over time, start by parking in the Liquid Fund.

This preserves capital and gives stable NAV, allowing smooth STP withdrawals.

You may consider shifting to Short Term Fund after 6-12 months if markets are volatile.

But for initial parking, Liquid Fund is preferred.

STP Duration and Strategy
Your investment horizon is 6 years. STP duration should align with that.

A 24 to 36 months STP period is usually good for phased equity entry.

STP over 2 to 3 years reduces risk of lump sum timing.

After STP completion, you can stay fully invested in equity funds.

Remaining lump sum parked in liquid or short term fund can be withdrawn gradually.

STP intervals of monthly or quarterly are better to spread market risk.

Monthly STP is common and convenient.

STP amount depends on total lump sum and your risk tolerance.

For Rs. 10 lakh lump sum and 36 months STP, you can start with Rs. 25,000–30,000 per month.

This balances steady equity exposure and capital preservation.

You can increase STP amount if markets dip.

Flexibility in STP helps capture market volatility better.

Choice of Equity Funds for STP
You currently have Nippon and ICICI Large Cap, HDFC Mid Cap, Nippon Multi Cap, and HDFC Hybrid Equity.

Large cap funds are more stable and less volatile.

Mid cap funds offer higher growth but more volatility.

Multi cap funds give diversified exposure across market caps.

Hybrid equity funds blend equity and debt, reducing volatility.

For STP, using a mix is wise.

Large cap funds can be the core of STP.

Add some mid cap and multi cap funds for growth.

Hybrid funds can be considered if you want moderate risk.

Given your horizon of 6 years, you can have about 50-60% in large and multi cap funds.

30-40% in mid cap funds, balancing risk and reward.

10-15% in hybrid equity funds for stability.

Since you already have these funds, no need to open a new fund.

Ensure funds have good track records and consistent performance.

Avoid over-diversification. Too many funds dilute focus.

You can create an STP basket from 3-4 funds.

For example, monthly STP split: 50% to large cap, 30% to mid cap, 20% to multi cap or hybrid.

STP Amounts and Monitoring
Decide STP amount based on lump sum parked and your cash flow needs.

Rs. 25,000 to 30,000 per month is a reasonable start.

You can increase if market dips or reduce in rising markets.

Review fund performance every 6 months to 1 year.

Switch funds if underperforming for long periods.

Avoid frequent changes to stay invested.

Rebalance portfolio yearly based on market changes and goals.

Keep long term horizon in mind; avoid panic during volatility.

Tax and Withdrawal Planning
STP is a transfer, so not a redemption for tax purposes until units are sold.

Equity fund gains above Rs. 1.25 lakh are taxed at 12.5% LTCG.

Short term capital gains in equity taxed at 15%.

Debt funds taxed as per your slab rates.

Use STP to reduce lump sum exposure risk.

After STP completes, hold for at least 3-4 years for best returns.

Avoid premature withdrawals to minimise tax impact.

Final Insights
Park lump sum initially in liquid fund for safety and liquidity.

Start STP monthly for 24-36 months into a mix of large, mid, and multi cap funds.

Hybrid equity fund can add stability but keep allocation small.

Monitor portfolio yearly and rebalance if needed.

No need for new fund if current ones perform well and cover your risk.

STP amount should match your comfort and liquidity needs.

Patience is key for 6-year horizon; avoid rash changes.

Your plan is solid. Execution with discipline will give good outcomes.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |8439 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 15, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - May 02, 2025
Money
Dear Sir, 1. Which is wise decision to invest whether in Flat purchasing Mumbai or Pune for about 85 lacs-2 BHK ( 70% should be loan ). Or go for Plot Purchase of around 2000 sq,ft in Nagpur of around 40 lacs with minimal loan amount. Which investment will provide good returns after 10 yrs. However, I have already two flat in two different city ( Mumbai and Nagpur) one debt free and another loan is continuing of 20 K EMI/month. How much inflation can we assume while in Flat and Plot for next 10 years. 2. Most probably i am thinking to move to Nagpur after 10 yrs ( Post retirement) , so suggest its wise decision to purchase plot now to do construction after 5-8 yrs. Or shall I purchase Plot when in i required to construct the independent house. Which should be profitable. 3. If you ask about the invest in Market or SIP . Right now I am 49 and investing in SIP of around 25K /month, Equity long term 1.5 lacs portfolio of around 20 lacs. PPF of around 6 lacs , LIC yearly 2.22 lacs premium and maturity shall be of around 50-6- lacs in different phase and life risk cover of around 80 lacs. Mediclaim of around 25 lacs cover. FD of around 25 lacs ( wants to invest in Flat or Plot) So pls suggest shall i add anything to improve my post retirement plan, cause my daughter is of only 5yrs old and wants to plan funds for her education in future. So kindly suggest . In the view of above scenario what is the best option and your suggestions to plan better. Regards
Ans: You have clearly outlined your financial position, goals, and decisions you are considering. It shows thoughtful planning and awareness about your future needs.

You have accumulated a solid financial base with multiple income-producing assets and long-term investments.

Now, let’s assess your situation from all angles and provide detailed suggestions for your post-retirement and daughter’s education planning.

Real Estate Decision – Flat or Plot?
You are considering a 2 BHK flat in Mumbai or Pune for Rs. 85 lakhs.

Around 70% of this cost would be through a home loan.

Alternatively, you are considering a 2000 sq.ft plot in Nagpur for Rs. 40 lakhs.

You already own two flats – one in Mumbai and one in Nagpur.

One of them is debt-free. The other has an EMI of Rs. 20,000 per month.

Adding a third property with a high loan burden may not be ideal.

Real estate is illiquid. It takes time to sell when needed.

Rental income is usually low in proportion to property cost.

Maintenance, taxes, legal costs, and vacancy risks reduce actual returns.

Real estate requires time, management, and ongoing financial attention.

Holding too much of your net worth in property creates concentration risk.

In your case, more real estate investment is not recommended.

You already have sufficient exposure through two flats.

Inflation in Property: Flat vs Plot
Over the next 10 years, inflation in property can vary across cities.

Flat prices usually grow at 5% to 7% per year.

But this is before deducting maintenance, property tax, and loan interest.

Plot prices may grow better in tier 2 cities like Nagpur.

Plot returns depend on location, infrastructure, and demand growth.

Historically, land appreciates better but does not generate any cash flow.

Flat gives rental income but has lower appreciation due to depreciation.

In the next decade, even 6%-8% annual growth will be considered decent.

So, neither flat nor plot is a guaranteed high-return asset.

That’s why mutual funds with flexibility and compounding are better long term.

Thinking of Shifting to Nagpur After Retirement?
You are thinking of settling in Nagpur post-retirement.

That is a clear and positive plan.

In this case, it’s not urgent to buy a plot right now.

You can wait and assess the locality and infrastructure after a few years.

Plot can be purchased 3 to 5 years before you need to build.

This gives you better clarity of available choices and better prices.

You also avoid keeping funds blocked in an idle land.

That money can work better for you in mutual funds and long-term growth options.

Later, you can buy a plot with maturity money from mutual funds, LIC, or FDs.

So, there is no need to rush into plot purchase today.

Should You Invest Rs. 40 to 85 Lakhs in Real Estate Now?
No, that may not be the most optimal decision.

Instead of investing in a third property, consider diversifying.

Real estate makes sense only when there is long-term use or rental value.

Mutual funds offer better liquidity, flexibility, and compounding benefits.

At 49, it’s time to make wealth work efficiently, not just grow size.

You can earn higher real returns through well-selected equity mutual funds.

Mutual funds also give you the option to withdraw as per need.

Property cannot be partially sold or withdrawn when needed.

Focus on financial assets that align with future expenses and goals.

Assessment of Current Investment Position
Monthly SIP of Rs. 25,000 is a strong and consistent investment habit.

Your mutual fund portfolio is around Rs. 20 lakhs. That is a good base.

Equity long-term capital gains are well-positioned for goal-based compounding.

PPF corpus of Rs. 6 lakhs adds safety and tax-free return.

LIC premiums of Rs. 2.22 lakhs per year need closer review.

Maturity value is around Rs. 50 to 60 lakhs across different policies.

Life risk cover of Rs. 80 lakhs is there. That offers some protection.

You also have Rs. 25 lakhs in FDs for immediate use.

Mediclaim cover of Rs. 25 lakhs is very good. It gives peace of mind.

All in all, your foundation is stable. But it can be sharpened.

What to Do With LIC Policies?
Review each LIC policy individually.

Check surrender value and maturity benefit vs premium paid.

If returns are below 5% annually, they are destroying your wealth.

Traditional insurance gives very low returns due to high costs.

Surrender poor-performing LIC policies and reinvest in mutual funds.

Use the maturity of good policies to support post-retirement needs.

Avoid mixing insurance and investment in future. Keep them separate.

Buy pure term cover for protection. Use mutual funds for investing.

This brings clarity, better returns, and tax-efficiency.

Planning for Daughter’s Education
Your daughter is 5 years old. Higher education will begin in 12 years.

That gives you a good time horizon to build a separate corpus.

Open a child goal SIP in a multi cap or balanced advantage fund.

Start investing minimum Rs. 10,000 per month towards this goal.

Step it up by 10% every year to match your income growth.

Keep this SIP separate from your retirement portfolio.

Do not mix children’s education fund with any other goal.

Track this goal using a calculator and review yearly.

Use long-term capital gains above Rs. 1.25 lakh judiciously as per new tax rules.

Enhancing Your Post-Retirement Plan
Post-retirement income should come from a mix of safe and growth assets.

Mutual funds in SWP mode give flexibility and steady income.

FD can be kept for 3 to 4 years of expenses for safety.

PPF maturity, LIC maturity, and NPS maturity should be staggered.

SIPs should be continued till age 60 and even beyond if possible.

Avoid holding excessive FD and real estate beyond 60 years.

Build at least Rs. 2 crores retirement corpus by age 60.

For that, continue SIPs with 10% step-up, focus on equity and hybrid funds.

Reduce property burden. Avoid taking large new loans now.

Invest more in mutual funds with the Rs. 25 lakh FD amount.

That will compound better and give you flexibility later.

Reallocate idle LIC premiums to higher-return options gradually.

Additional Suggestions
Do not invest in direct equity unless you can track daily.

Equity investing requires deep research, risk handling, and continuous tracking.

Instead, choose regular mutual fund plans with help of CFP.

Regular plans provide advisory, behavioural guidance, and rebalancing support.

Direct plans do not give any handholding or personalised planning.

Retirement, education, and healthcare goals need guided planning.

Avoid index funds. They lack downside protection and are rigid.

Actively managed funds perform better with fund manager strategies.

You can opt for balanced advantage funds in later years for stability.

Track inflation at 6% average for expenses. Use 8% return expectation for planning.

Do not overspend or overcommit in large-ticket assets now.

Finally
You are financially disciplined and forward-thinking. That is a strong quality.

Avoid new flat or plot now. Real estate already has high exposure in your portfolio.

Mutual funds will give you better returns, liquidity, and peace of mind.

Start separate SIPs for your daughter’s education. Keep it focused and growing.

Revisit all LIC policies. Exit low-return ones and shift to equity funds.

Invest your Rs. 25 lakhs FD in staggered manner into quality mutual funds.

Don’t increase loan burden. At age 49, focus on building financial flexibility.

Balance growth with safety. Mix equity, hybrid, and debt in right proportion.

With 10 years to retirement, create a clear retirement income strategy.

Continue protection with term cover and mediclaim. Those are non-negotiable.

Track goals yearly. Seek help from a Certified Financial Planner for a personalised plan.

The key to retirement success is goal-based investing, not asset hoarding.

Your wealth must support your dreams and responsibilities with ease.

Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |8439 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 15, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - May 01, 2025
Money
Am 52, earn 50 L annual as salary, invest 1+L monthly and some lumpsum (ocassionally) in SIP in mix of Large, Mid, Small & Flexi Cap and have built a corpus of 5+cr in MF; have 30+L in PPF and 2 SSY accounts (investing 1.5L each annually since 2017) with 20 L each for 2 daughters; have own house and no outstanding or loans. On inheritance will have a flat (value 80 L- 1cr). My wife works with Salary 30+ L. (When) can I retire early.
Ans: You are in a strong position. Let us evaluate your early retirement readiness in a detailed, practical and holistic way.

Below is a complete assessment from a Certified Financial Planner’s lens.

Cash Flow Stability
Your salary is Rs. 50 lakh annually. That gives you approx Rs. 3 lakh monthly post-tax.

You invest over Rs. 1 lakh monthly. This means your savings rate is excellent.

Your wife earns over Rs. 30 lakh annually. This adds great strength to your family’s financial cushion.

No loans or EMIs. That frees up your entire income for lifestyle and savings.

You are able to manage expenses, save well and still maintain your lifestyle. That’s ideal.

Asset Base – Solid Foundation
Rs. 5 crore in mutual funds shows strong discipline over many years.

Rs. 30+ lakh in PPF gives tax-free and safe returns till maturity.

Two Sukanya Samriddhi accounts with Rs. 20 lakh each is excellent for your daughters’ future.

You own your house. That cuts future rental outflow.

You will inherit a flat worth Rs. 80 lakh to Rs. 1 crore. That adds more flexibility post-retirement.

No real estate investment is ideal. That keeps your liquidity high.

Mutual Fund Portfolio Health
You invest in a mix of large, mid, small, and flexi-cap funds.

This gives your portfolio balance of growth and stability.

You also invest lumpsum sometimes. That helps during market corrections.

Staying invested across market cycles improves long-term returns.

You’ve avoided index funds. That is good. Actively managed funds do better in India.

Fund managers actively adjust holdings based on markets. Index funds don’t do that.

Actively managed funds can beat inflation and generate alpha. Index funds can't.

You’ve not gone for direct funds. That is good for you.

With a CFP-backed MFD, you get regular review, asset rebalancing and risk control.

Direct funds don’t offer guidance. They suit only full-time experts.

MFDs aligned with CFPs help you stay invested during volatility. That matters.

Children’s Education Planning
Your daughters’ SSY balances are around Rs. 20 lakh each.

You invest Rs. 1.5 lakh per year in both. That’s maximum allowed.

SSY is tax-free and government backed. Very safe.

At maturity, each account can support higher education or initial marriage costs.

Along with mutual funds and PPF, you’re on track to fund both daughters’ goals.

Ensure mutual funds are earmarked with goal-based approach. Not general corpus.

Also consider having SIPs separately tagged to each daughter’s milestone.

Don’t redeem PPF or SSY unless necessary. Let them compound.

Retirement Corpus Requirement
If you retire now, you need passive income to cover expenses.

Let’s assume Rs. 1.5 to 2 lakh monthly expenses post-retirement. Adjusted for lifestyle.

That’s Rs. 18–24 lakh per year. Growing each year due to inflation.

You will need at least Rs. 5 to 6 crore invested smartly. That can generate this income.

You already have Rs. 5 crore+ in MFs. That’s close.

PPF and SSY are also future buffers. They mature tax-free.

Your wife’s income of Rs. 30 lakh/year can support family till you fully stop working.

Inheritance of Rs. 80 lakh–1 crore adds further backup.

So even if you retire now, you have fallback income and asset base.

Spouse Income and Planning
Your wife’s income adds stability. She can support some family costs for now.

But her retirement plan should also be worked out.

She may choose to work for 8–10 more years. Or take a break.

Create parallel investments in her name also. That helps post-retirement balance.

Use her Section 80C, 80D, and other deductions. Optimise tax.

Consider SIPs and lump sum in her name also. Track goals individually.

Build a joint passive income plan. Not just your side alone.

Insurance and Contingency
Ensure health insurance of at least Rs. 15–20 lakh for family.

Include super top-up for extra protection. Medical costs rise faster than inflation.

Term insurance is not priority now if assets > liabilities. But review once.

Emergency fund of 6 months’ expenses is needed in liquid fund or FD.

If not done already, create that immediately.

Keep it away from market volatility.

Tax Efficiency Post Retirement
After retirement, plan SWP from mutual funds.

Use debt and equity funds smartly for tax efficiency.

LTCG on equity funds above Rs. 1.25 lakh now taxed at 12.5%.

STCG taxed at 20%. Plan redemptions smartly.

Debt funds are taxed as per your slab. So balance carefully.

Use PPF and SSY withdrawals tax-free. Delay withdrawals for better maturity value.

Retire early, but reduce tax drag with withdrawal strategy.

Early Retirement Readiness – Final Evaluation
You can consider early retirement now.

You have strong corpus, no loan, and regular family income.

Your daughters’ education is on track. House is owned.

You will get inheritance in coming years. That gives more comfort.

If you retire today, do phased withdrawal and reduce spending spike.

You can also work part-time or consult. That gives purpose and slow transition.

Don't exit equity fully. Stay invested for 25–30 more years of life.

Inflation will erode value. You need growth even in retirement.

You don’t need annuities. They give poor returns and no growth.

Your MF portfolio gives you better post-tax income.

Avoid any real estate investments now. Keep flexibility high.

You’ve avoided ULIPs or endowment plans. That’s good. No surrender needed.

Focus now on asset allocation, tax planning and joint family goals.

With a CFP-backed review each year, you can retire with confidence.

Finally
You have built a strong foundation. Your discipline shows in your portfolio.

You can retire today. Or in 1–2 years with complete comfort.

The key now is smooth transition, not rushing out suddenly.

Create a withdrawal plan. Align goals with spouse.

Secure your health, children’s education and your peace of mind.

Keep reviewing every year with a trusted CFP-backed MFD.

Don’t panic in market falls. Stay long in equities.

You’ve earned this phase. Make it count wisely.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Investment in securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related document carefully before investing. The securities quoted are for illustration only and are not recommendatory. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information and as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision. RediffGURUS is an intermediary as per India's Information Technology Act.

Close  

You haven't logged in yet. To ask a question, Please Log in below
Login

A verification OTP will be sent to this
Mobile Number / Email

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to

Resend OTP in120seconds

Dear User, You have not registered yet. Please register by filling the fields below to get expert answers from our Gurus
Sign up

By signing up, you agree to our
Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy

Already have an account?

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to Mobile

Resend OTP in120seconds

x