Need Expert Advice?Our Gurus Can Help
Vipul

Vipul Bhavsar  |150 Answers  |Ask -

Tax Expert - Answered on Jun 10, 2026

Vipul Bhavsar is a chartered accountant from The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India. He has over 16 years of experience in corporate advisory, taxation and financial reporting.
His interest areas are consulting, income tax, GST and due diligence.
He founded his CA firm, V J Bhavsar and Associates, in 2010 through which he offers services like virtual CFO, trademark registrations, company /LLP formation, MIS reporting, audit, tax and TDS compliances, accounts receivable/payable management and payroll processing.... more
Vivek Question by Vivek on Jun 08, 2026Hindi
Money

I am a retired person having incomes from pension, interests and occasional capital gains which are received in my savings bank account with me as first holder and my wife as joint hloder.These incomes are duly account in my ITR.My wife has separate interest income (small amount) from individual single SB AC in her name.As my wife turns 60, I plan to take a SCSS in her name (me as joint holder);from my retirement savings parked in our joint account.Can I add interest income from this SCSS (recd in joint account with me as first holder) in my ITR or is it necessary to file separate ITR for my wife for the same?

Ans: According to clubbing provision, the Interest on SCSS though in her name shall be considered to be your income. You need to disclose it in your ITR

Vipul Jeevankumar Bhavsar
Chartered Accountant
www.capitalca.in
DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information to be as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision.
Money

You may like to see similar questions and answers below

Mihir

Mihir Tanna  |1120 Answers  |Ask -

Tax Expert - Answered on Dec 20, 2022

Listen
Money
I am a retired govt. servant and get pension. Also I get Interest from Deposits, Saving and Acc. Int. I show this income in my Income Tax returns filed in Form ITR-1 SAHAJ. During the current Financial Year I have received the maturity amount of my PPF maintained in the Post Office. Out of the amount received I have a certain amount given as a gift to my spouse. She has invested the said amount received by her from me as a gift in the SCSS A/C and gets interest on that amount. I want to know whether the amount she receives as interest from the amount given by me is to be included in my income and to be shown in the Income Tax Return. If so, at what place i.e. in which column? I have to show the income so included as I do not see such places or column. In which I have to indicate this amount Sr. No. B3 Income from Other Sources along with the Interest received by me from Deposit etc. Since the amount of interest received by my spouse is included in my Income, Whether the said amount is also to be shown in her Income Tax Return or otherwise? As if it is to be shown in her return also then there will be duplication. This clarification is sought as I file my return myself and since the notice I or my wife may not get. I hope you will kindly guide me in this regard and oblige us. Thank you in advance.
Ans: If taxpayer directly or indirectly transfers an asset to spouse for inadequate consideration than Income from such asset is clubbed in the hands of the transferor. Transferor (taxpayer) should show such income in Schedule SPI of Income Tax Return filed by such tax payer in whose hands income is clubbed. No need to show said income in the income tax return of spouse. 

..Read more

Moneywize

Moneywize   | Answer  |Ask -

Financial Planner - Answered on Jan 29, 2024

Asked by Anonymous - Jan 29, 2024Hindi
Listen
Money
I filed my ITR in July 30, 2023 clubbing together my wife's income, ITR processed and Refund credited to my Bank a/c. I invest/trade in equities in our names but out of my own funds, wife has no fund of her own. I have been filing ITR for last 20 yrs clubbing wife's income. (*) On 11/11/23 an SMS came stating that her income for AY 2023-24 has not been filed and asked to visit ITax Compliance Portal and respond under e-campaign which I did and gave response stating my ITR Acknowedgement No. and Date of filing. (*) Is it necessary to file separate ITR for her? Can IT Dept start proceeding etc against her? Thank you very much Awaiting your reply asap.
Ans: There could be many layers to it, and so it's important to consult with a tax professional for tailored solution to your specific situation.

When you file your income tax return (ITR) by clubbing your wife's income, it typically means that both your incomes are reported together in a single return. In such cases, it's important to ensure that all relevant details and incomes are correctly disclosed while filing the ITR.

Regarding the SMS you received, it's possible that there might be some discrepancy or confusion in the information received by the income tax department. Responding to the e-campaign with your ITR Acknowledgment Number and the date of filing should provide them with the necessary information.

However, if your wife has a separate source of income or if there are specific requirements for her to file a separate return, it's advisable to clarify this with a tax professional. The income tax department may require separate filings for individuals with their own sources of income.

If there are any discrepancies or if the income tax department requires additional information, they may initiate proceedings. It's crucial to respond to any communication from the tax department promptly and accurately.

To ensure you have the most accurate and up-to-date information, consider consulting with a tax professional or reaching out to the income tax department directly to seek more clarification on the specific requirements for your situation.

..Read more

Latest Questions
Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |11334 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jul 15, 2026

Asked by Anonymous - Jul 15, 2026
Money
I am a 37 year old woman working in a private sector company in India with no dependents and 74K monthly net take home + 1L annual bonus. I have about 37.62L in PPF (continuing 1.5L yearly, already included for 2026-27), 8.48L in PF (employee+employer 6.6K monthly as present, deducted before net take home salary 74K), 10.95L in FD/RD, 98K in savings account, own sedan car purchased in 2017, MF balance of 12.28L out of which investment itself is 12.02L (This includes my 2 tier emergency fund 4L in edelweiss liquid fund + 2L in edelweiss equity savings fund) and ETF balance of 68.9K with investment of 57.8K. Planning to gift 3L from my liquid fund to my younger brother for his car purchase down payment within next 4-5 months. My current 40K Monthly SIPs from jul 2026 onwards are as follows: Parag Parikh Flexi Cap Fund 10000, HDFC Flexi Cap Fund 10000, HDFC Mid Cap Opp Fund 10000, Bandhan Small Cap Fund 4000, Icici Prudential Gold ETF 4000, Motilal Oswal Nasdaq 100 ETF 2000. I am investing in 2 flexi caps because both of them have minimum overlap with different philosophies. Planned to increase 40K SIPs to 60K from jul 2027 onwards as follows: Parag Parikh Flexi Cap Fund 16000, HDFC Flexi Cap Fund 16000, HDFC Mid Cap Opp Fund 16000, Bandhan Small Cap Fund 6000, Icici Prudential Gold ETF 4000, Motilal Oswal Nasdaq 100 ETF 2000. I started investing in MF/ETFs quite late from jul 2025 and in the past 1 yr, I haven't received much returns because of many reasons like the geopolitical tensions/issues, market consolidations, overvaluations, etc. I have medium risk appetite with the goal of financial freedom at the earliest and long term wealth creation that can comfortably sustain my daily needs and my avid travelling interests. My goal is min. 6Cr by the time I am 48-50 years old. Am I on the right track considering inflation and current geopolitical and market conditions in india. Also, I only have office provided 5L health insurance as of now. Planning to take another personal one for 10-15L with or without further super top up before I turn 40 with min. premium. Had shortlisted HDFC ergo optima secure +. Any suggestions.
Ans: You have built a very strong foundation already.

At age 37, having more than Rs.70 lakh across PPF, PF, FDs, mutual funds, ETFs and cash is a good achievement. More importantly, you have very low dependency risk and a healthy savings rate. That gives you flexibility and speed in wealth creation.

» Overall Financial Position

– Your asset allocation is reasonably balanced.

– PPF and PF together form a strong debt component.

– FDs and emergency funds provide stability.

– Equity exposure is still at a stage where it can grow significantly over the next 10-15 years.

– No dependent responsibilities at present gives you an additional advantage.

– The planned gift of Rs.3 lakh to your brother is manageable from your overall financial position.

– Even after the gift, your emergency reserve remains adequate.

» Are You On Track For Financial Freedom?

– Based on your current corpus and planned SIP increase, you are moving in the right direction.

– The biggest positive is that you have started investing seriously and are already planning a SIP step-up.

– Many investors focus only on current returns.

– Wealth creation actually depends more on consistency and increasing investments.

– The next 10-13 years will be far more important than the first year.

– Your target of Rs.6 crore by age 48-50 looks achievable if:

SIPs continue without interruption.
Annual increments lead to higher investments.
Major withdrawals are avoided.
Equity allocation remains intact during market corrections.

– Inflation will definitely reduce future purchasing power.

– However, your target corpus appears meaningful even after considering inflation.

– The key risk is not inflation.

– The bigger risk is stopping SIPs during market stress.

» About The Low Returns In The Last One Year

– What you are experiencing is normal.

– One year is too short to judge an equity portfolio.

– Markets have seen valuation concerns, geopolitical tensions and earnings adjustments.

– Such phases are common.

– Long-term wealth is usually created during these boring and frustrating periods.

– Investors who stay invested during consolidation phases often benefit later.

– A portfolio should ideally be judged over 7-10 years, not 12 months.

» Review Of Your SIP Structure

– Your allocation is sensible.

– Large and flexible category exposure forms the core.

– Mid-cap allocation adds growth potential.

– Small-cap exposure is controlled and not excessive.

– Gold allocation acts as a hedge.

– Overall portfolio appears suitable for a medium-risk investor with long-term goals.

– The planned increase from Rs.40,000 to Rs.60,000 is an excellent move.

– In fact, increasing investments every year will contribute more than trying to predict markets.

» Having Two Flexi-Cap Funds

– Your reasoning is valid.

– Different investment styles can reduce dependence on one fund management approach.

– Style diversification is often overlooked by investors.

– Low portfolio overlap can also improve diversification.

– However, review performance every 3-5 years.

– Avoid frequent switching based on short-term rankings.

» About Gold Allocation

– Gold has a role in portfolio stability.

– It helps during uncertain global situations.

– It can also provide diversification when equities face pressure.

– Keep gold as a supporting asset rather than a primary wealth creator.

» About International ETF Exposure

– International diversification is useful.

– It reduces dependence on a single economy.

– However, ETFs have certain limitations.

– ETFs simply track an index.

– They cannot avoid weak companies within that index.

– They remain fully invested even during expensive market phases.

– There is no active fund manager taking valuation calls.

– Market downturns are fully reflected in ETF returns.

– Tracking errors can also impact performance.

– Liquidity may become an issue in some ETFs.

– Actively managed international funds can provide better flexibility.

– Skilled fund managers can focus on stronger businesses and avoid weaker segments.

– They can also adjust allocations based on valuations and opportunities.

» Emergency Fund Review

– Presently you have a good emergency setup.

– The liquid component provides immediate access.

– The equity savings component offers some growth potential.

– After gifting Rs.3 lakh, ensure at least 6-9 months of expenses remain easily accessible.

– Since you work in the private sector, job-loss protection is important.

» Health Insurance Review

– This is one area requiring quicker action.

– Relying only on employer health insurance is risky.

– A job change or job loss can create a coverage gap.

– Medical inflation is increasing rapidly.

– Buying personal health insurance earlier helps in multiple ways.

– Premiums remain lower.

– Waiting periods start earlier.

– Future health changes may not affect eligibility.

– A personal base cover of Rs.10-15 lakh is reasonable.

– A super top-up can provide very cost-effective additional protection.

– A combination of base policy plus super top-up often provides stronger coverage than only increasing the base policy.

– Do not postpone this until age 40.

– Taking it now may be more beneficial.

» Other Risk Management Areas

– Review personal accident insurance.

– Review disability protection.

– These are often ignored.

– A disability can affect income far more than a hospitalisation event.

– Since your income depends on employment, income protection deserves attention.

» Tax Efficiency

– Continue maximising PPF contribution.

– PF contribution adds long-term stability.

– Equity investments should remain focused on long-term holding periods.

– Frequent buying and selling may create unnecessary tax leakage.

– Remember:

LTCG above Rs.1.25 lakh is taxed at 12.5%.
STCG is taxed at 20%.

– Long holding periods generally improve tax efficiency.

» Finally

– Your financial journey is progressing well.

– The strongest positives are disciplined savings, reasonable diversification, increasing SIPs and limited liabilities.

– I would rate your overall financial structure as above average for your age.

– Health insurance should be the immediate priority.

– Continue annual SIP increases whenever income rises.

– Stay patient with equities.

– The next decade can be very rewarding if consistency remains intact.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

AMFI-Registered MFD – ARN 4188

www.holisticinvestment.in

https://www.linkedin.com/in/ramalingamcfp/

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |11334 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jul 15, 2026

Asked by Anonymous - Jul 15, 2026
Money
I am a 37 year old woman working in a private sector company in India with no dependents and 74K monthly net take home + 1L annual bonus. I have about 37.62L in PPF (continuing 1.5L yearly, already included for 2026-27), 8.48L in PF (employee+employer 6.6K monthly as present, deducted before net take home salary 74K), 10.95L in FD/RD, 98K in savings account, own sedan car purchased in 2017, MF balance of 12.28L out of which investment itself is 12.02L (This includes my 2 tier emergency fund 4L in edelweiss liquid fund + 2L in edelweiss equity savings fund) and ETF balance of 68.9K with investment of 57.8K. Planning to gift 3L from my liquid fund to my younger brother for his car purchase down payment within next 4-5 months. My current 40K Monthly SIPs from jul 2026 onwards are as follows: Parag Parikh Flexi Cap Fund 10000, HDFC Flexi Cap Fund 10000, HDFC Mid Cap Opp Fund 10000, Bandhan Small Cap Fund 4000, Icici Prudential Gold ETF 4000, Motilal Oswal Nasdaq 100 ETF 2000. I am investing in 2 flexi caps because both of them have minimum overlap with different philosophies. Planned to increase 40K SIPs to 60K from jul 2027 onwards as follows: Parag Parikh Flexi Cap Fund 16000, HDFC Flexi Cap Fund 16000, HDFC Mid Cap Opp Fund 16000, Bandhan Small Cap Fund 6000, Icici Prudential Gold ETF 4000, Motilal Oswal Nasdaq 100 ETF 2000. I started investing in MF/ETFs quite late from jul 2025 and in the past 1 yr, I haven't received much returns because of many reasons like the geopolitical tensions/issues, market consolidations, overvaluations, etc. I have medium risk appetite with the goal of financial freedom at the earliest and long term wealth creation that can comfortably sustain my daily needs and my avid travelling interests. My goal is min. 6Cr by the time I am 48-50 years old. Am I on the right track considering inflation and current geopolitical and market conditions in india. Also, I only have office provided 5L health insurance as of now. Planning to take another personal one for 10-15L with or without further super top up before I turn 40 with min. premium. Had shortlisted HDFC ergo optima secure +. Any suggestions
Ans: You have built a very strong foundation already.

At age 37, having more than Rs.70 lakh across PPF, PF, FDs, mutual funds, ETFs and cash is a good achievement. More importantly, you have very low dependency risk and a healthy savings rate. That gives you flexibility and speed in wealth creation.

» Overall Financial Position

– Your asset allocation is reasonably balanced.

– PPF and PF together form a strong debt component.

– FDs and emergency funds provide stability.

– Equity exposure is still at a stage where it can grow significantly over the next 10-15 years.

– No dependent responsibilities at present gives you an additional advantage.

– The planned gift of Rs.3 lakh to your brother is manageable from your overall financial position.

– Even after the gift, your emergency reserve remains adequate.

» Are You On Track For Financial Freedom?

– Based on your current corpus and planned SIP increase, you are moving in the right direction.

– The biggest positive is that you have started investing seriously and are already planning a SIP step-up.

– Many investors focus only on current returns.

– Wealth creation actually depends more on consistency and increasing investments.

– The next 10-13 years will be far more important than the first year.

– Your target of Rs.6 crore by age 48-50 looks achievable if:

SIPs continue without interruption.
Annual increments lead to higher investments.
Major withdrawals are avoided.
Equity allocation remains intact during market corrections.

– Inflation will definitely reduce future purchasing power.

– However, your target corpus appears meaningful even after considering inflation.

– The key risk is not inflation.

– The bigger risk is stopping SIPs during market stress.

» About The Low Returns In The Last One Year

– What you are experiencing is normal.

– One year is too short to judge an equity portfolio.

– Markets have seen valuation concerns, geopolitical tensions and earnings adjustments.

– Such phases are common.

– Long-term wealth is usually created during these boring and frustrating periods.

– Investors who stay invested during consolidation phases often benefit later.

– A portfolio should ideally be judged over 7-10 years, not 12 months.

» Review Of Your SIP Structure

– Your allocation is sensible.

– Large and flexible category exposure forms the core.

– Mid-cap allocation adds growth potential.

– Small-cap exposure is controlled and not excessive.

– Gold allocation acts as a hedge.

– Overall portfolio appears suitable for a medium-risk investor with long-term goals.

– The planned increase from Rs.40,000 to Rs.60,000 is an excellent move.

– In fact, increasing investments every year will contribute more than trying to predict markets.

» Having Two Flexi-Cap Funds

– Your reasoning is valid.

– Different investment styles can reduce dependence on one fund management approach.

– Style diversification is often overlooked by investors.

– Low portfolio overlap can also improve diversification.

– However, review performance every 3-5 years.

– Avoid frequent switching based on short-term rankings.

» About Gold Allocation

– Gold has a role in portfolio stability.

– It helps during uncertain global situations.

– It can also provide diversification when equities face pressure.

– Keep gold as a supporting asset rather than a primary wealth creator.

» About International ETF Exposure

– International diversification is useful.

– It reduces dependence on a single economy.

– However, ETFs have certain limitations.

– ETFs simply track an index.

– They cannot avoid weak companies within that index.

– They remain fully invested even during expensive market phases.

– There is no active fund manager taking valuation calls.

– Market downturns are fully reflected in ETF returns.

– Tracking errors can also impact performance.

– Liquidity may become an issue in some ETFs.

– Actively managed international funds can provide better flexibility.

– Skilled fund managers can focus on stronger businesses and avoid weaker segments.

– They can also adjust allocations based on valuations and opportunities.

» Emergency Fund Review

– Presently you have a good emergency setup.

– The liquid component provides immediate access.

– The equity savings component offers some growth potential.

– After gifting Rs.3 lakh, ensure at least 6-9 months of expenses remain easily accessible.

– Since you work in the private sector, job-loss protection is important.

» Health Insurance Review

– This is one area requiring quicker action.

– Relying only on employer health insurance is risky.

– A job change or job loss can create a coverage gap.

– Medical inflation is increasing rapidly.

– Buying personal health insurance earlier helps in multiple ways.

– Premiums remain lower.

– Waiting periods start earlier.

– Future health changes may not affect eligibility.

– A personal base cover of Rs.10-15 lakh is reasonable.

– A super top-up can provide very cost-effective additional protection.

– A combination of base policy plus super top-up often provides stronger coverage than only increasing the base policy.

– Do not postpone this until age 40.

– Taking it now may be more beneficial.

» Other Risk Management Areas

– Review personal accident insurance.

– Review disability protection.

– These are often ignored.

– A disability can affect income far more than a hospitalisation event.

– Since your income depends on employment, income protection deserves attention.

» Tax Efficiency

– Continue maximising PPF contribution.

– PF contribution adds long-term stability.

– Equity investments should remain focused on long-term holding periods.

– Frequent buying and selling may create unnecessary tax leakage.

– Remember:

LTCG above Rs.1.25 lakh is taxed at 12.5%.
STCG is taxed at 20%.

– Long holding periods generally improve tax efficiency.

» Finally

– Your financial journey is progressing well.

– The strongest positives are disciplined savings, reasonable diversification, increasing SIPs and limited liabilities.

– I would rate your overall financial structure as above average for your age.

– Health insurance should be the immediate priority.

– Continue annual SIP increases whenever income rises.

– Stay patient with equities.

– The next decade can be very rewarding if consistency remains intact.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

AMFI-Registered MFD – ARN 4188

www.holisticinvestment.in

https://www.linkedin.com/in/ramalingamcfp/

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |11334 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jul 15, 2026

Money
should i continue policy number 884365028 taken in 2012 running up to 2037
Ans: To answer whether you should continue Policy No. 884365028 up to 2037, I need a few more details because the recommendation depends on the type of policy, benefits, and your current financial situation.

» Please Share These Details

Name of the insurance company.
Type of policy:
Traditional Endowment
Money Back
Whole Life
ULIP
Pension Plan
Term Insurance
Other
Annual premium amount.
Sum assured.
Maturity benefit projected by the insurer.
Current surrender value (if available).
Current paid-up value (if available).
Whether any riders are attached.
Your current age.
Purpose for which the policy was originally purchased.
Do you already have adequate term insurance and health insurance?

» Why These Details Matter

Some older policies provide very low long-term returns.
Some policies may be worth making paid-up instead of continuing.
Some policies may be better surrendered and the proceeds redirected to mutual funds.
In certain cases, continuing the policy may still make sense, especially if it is close to maturity or has valuable guarantees.

» Also Share

Total premiums paid till date.
Next premium due date.
Latest policy statement or benefit illustration details.

Once you provide these details, I can give a clear continue vs paid-up vs surrender recommendation with a complete 360-degree review.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

AMFI-Registered MFD – ARN 4188

www.holisticinvestment.in

https://www.linkedin.com/in/ramalingamcfp/

...Read more

DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Investment in securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related document carefully before investing. The securities quoted are for illustration only and are not recommendatory. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information and as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision. RediffGURUS is an intermediary as per India's Information Technology Act.

Close  

You haven't logged in yet. To ask a question, Please Log in below
Login

A verification OTP will be sent to this
Mobile Number / Email

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to

Resend OTP in120seconds

Dear User, You have not registered yet. Please register by filling the fields below to get expert answers from our Gurus
Sign up

By signing up, you agree to our
Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy

Already have an account?

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to Mobile

Resend OTP in120seconds

x