Home > Money > Question
Need Expert Advice?Our Gurus Can Help
Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |8940 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 13, 2025

Ramalingam Kalirajan has over 23 years of experience in mutual funds and financial planning.
He has an MBA in finance from the University of Madras and is a certified financial planner.
He is the director and chief financial planner at Holistic Investment, a Chennai-based firm that offers financial planning and wealth management advice.... more
Asked by Anonymous - May 13, 2025
Money

I have a home loan of 48lakhs in Tata Capital @8.85% Floating roi and currently 104 emis are left but i am getting offers from government bank @8.25% roi should i switch or should i continue with tata as they don't follow repo rates & how do i finish it asap with step up or extra emi payment if paid one extra emi per year please guide me

Ans: You are holding a home loan of Rs. 48 lakhs with Tata Capital.
The current rate is 8.85% (floating), and 104 EMIs are remaining.

You also have an offer from a government bank at 8.25% interest.
You are thinking of switching.

Also, you are keen to close the loan early using extra EMI or step-up method.
This is a great sign of financial discipline.

Let us evaluate everything carefully.

First, Review Your Current Home Loan Setup
Tata Capital charges 8.85% floating rate.

They don’t follow RBI repo rate directly.

That means your rate may not reduce quickly when RBI cuts repo rate.
Private NBFCs often link to internal benchmarks.

That gives them more control, less transparency.
This could lead to higher cost over time.

Second, Compare with Government Bank Offer
You are getting 8.25% from a government bank.

Most likely, it is linked to RBI repo rate.

That gives more transparency and faster rate reduction during cuts.
Also, public banks may give better customer support long term.

Lower rate and better structure both are positive.

Third, Cost of Switching Must Be Considered
Switching a home loan is not free.

There may be processing charges, legal, and valuation costs.

Sometimes the cost is Rs. 10,000 to Rs. 25,000.
This cost must be compared to interest saved.

If interest saving is big, switch is worth it.
If not, better to stay.

Fourth, Check the Remaining Loan Tenure
You have 104 EMIs left. That is around 8.5 years.

At this stage, interest portion is still high.

So switching now can still help.
If you were near the end of tenure, switching may not save much.

But you are in mid-to-late phase. It can still be useful.

Fifth, Repayment Strategy – Step-Up or Extra EMI
You want to close early using extra payments.

That’s a very powerful approach.

You can follow two smart strategies:

Step-Up EMI every year when your salary increases

Or pay one extra EMI every year

Even one extra EMI yearly will reduce the total EMIs by 5 to 6.
If you do this consistently, you can close loan at least 1 to 1.5 years early.

If you combine both methods, it becomes very powerful.

Sixth, Benefits of One Extra EMI Every Year
Loan tenure gets shorter.

You save a lot of interest.

Extra EMI reduces principal directly.
So next month’s interest becomes lesser.

This cycle keeps repeating.
So total interest goes down every year.

Seventh, Lump Sum Repayments are Also a Strong Option
Got bonus, incentives, or profits? Don’t spend fully.

Use part of it to repay principal.

Even Rs. 1 lakh lump sum once a year can reduce many EMIs.
You don’t need to wait for end of year.

Whenever cash is available, pay part pre-payment.
It saves interest from that month itself.

Eighth, Plan Your Repayment Calendar
Mark dates in calendar for extra payments.

Plan them with yearly increments or festival bonuses.

This gives clarity and target.
Don’t leave it to random mood or emotion.

Being organised gives confidence and results.

Ninth, Should You Switch Lender or Not?
Let us assess the switch properly:

You should switch if…

New lender is offering repo-linked rate (like EBLR)

Their service is reliable and terms are clear

The cost of switching is below Rs. 25,000

You will continue for at least 5 more years in loan

You can continue with Tata Capital if…

They are ready to match new rate (ask them first)

Your relationship and process is smooth there

Switch cost is high and savings are low

But if Tata is not reducing rate automatically,
and they don’t pass on rate cuts,
you are better off moving to a government bank.

Tenth, What to Watch While Switching
Don’t go for the lowest rate only. Check terms.

Some lenders increase rate quietly over time.

Ensure your new loan is linked to repo rate.
Not internal or fixed benchmark.

Ask for written confirmation.

Eleventh, Use a Certified Financial Planner for Help
A Certified Financial Planner will guide you smartly.

They assess switching cost, benefit, and fit for you.

They also help in calculating step-up EMI plans.
That saves time and gives clarity.

Twelfth, Avoid These Mistakes While Repaying Early
Don’t use emergency fund to prepay home loan.

Don’t break retirement investments to close loan.

Home loan is a long-term debt.
Closing early is good. But not at any cost.

Your future safety is more important than loan closure.

Thirteenth, Tax Benefit Angle
Home loan gives tax deduction under Section 80C and 24(b).

These reduce your tax outgo.

So don’t rush to close loan just for peace of mind.
Balance tax benefits with interest savings.

If your tax benefits are low, prepayment is more attractive.

Fourteenth, How Much Extra EMI You Can Afford
Start with one extra EMI per year.

If you get salary hike, increase EMI voluntarily.

Even 5% increase in EMI yearly helps a lot.
Don’t wait till you “feel rich”. Start small.

Let compounding of interest savings work for you.

Final Insights
You are already thinking in the right direction.
That is your biggest strength.

Tata Capital loan at 8.85% is slightly high.
If a government bank is giving 8.25% with repo-link, it is better.

But check the switching cost.
Also speak to Tata Capital once.

Ask them if they can reduce the rate.
If not, prepare to switch carefully.

Start one extra EMI per year.
Do part prepayment when bonus or gift money comes.

Plan a step-up increase in EMI every year with salary hike.
Keep emergency fund and retirement fund untouched.

You are on the path to a debt-free life.
With this focus, your goal is very much possible.

Get support from a Certified Financial Planner for exact steps.
You don’t have to do it alone.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment
DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information to be as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision.
Money

You may like to see similar questions and answers below

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |8940 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 15, 2025

Money
Hi , I have Home loan of Around 56 Lakhs. I'm paying an EMI of 40k per month which includes term insurance. After repo rate, I didn't opt- "Change in tenure" nor " Change in EMI". My interest rate was earlier 8.50% ..after change in repo rate it was 8.25%. I'm still paying same 40k per month. are they any disadvantages or advantages?
Ans: You are thoughtful and sincere in managing your finances. Paying a Rs. 56 lakh home loan with Rs. 40,000 EMI needs strong planning. You are doing a good job by not missing your EMI. Let us now analyse your home loan repayment in detail. This will help you understand the true financial impact. A 360-degree approach is used to evaluate your decision.

Loan Situation: Clear and Well-Structured

Your home loan is Rs. 56 lakhs. EMI is Rs. 40,000 per month.

Your earlier rate of interest was 8.50%. It is now reduced to 8.25%.

You have not changed your EMI amount or loan tenure after rate change.

Your EMI includes term insurance premium. That is a safe and responsible approach.

This means your monthly EMI has remained the same after repo rate reduction.

But the interest component of the EMI has now become slightly lower.

Hence, more portion of your EMI now goes towards principal repayment.

This is a good situation. But let us go deeper to see hidden advantages and disadvantages.

Not Opting for Tenure Reduction – Benefits and Risks

When interest rates fall, banks may give two options:

Either reduce EMI amount or reduce loan tenure.

You have not chosen either. That means your EMI is still Rs. 40,000.

Since rate has dropped to 8.25%, interest portion in EMI is less.

This means, your principal repayment is now a little faster.

Without doing anything, your loan may get closed a few months earlier.

That is the hidden benefit of not reducing EMI or changing tenure.

This approach will help reduce the total interest paid over the loan life.

Hence, you may become loan-free earlier than expected.

This works better than reducing EMI amount.

Reducing EMI slows down principal repayment.

That increases your total interest cost over years.

So, keeping EMI same after rate cut is smart and beneficial.

Missed Opportunity: Tenure Reduction Confirmation

Still, you should confirm with the bank whether tenure has reduced or not.

Sometimes banks keep the tenure unchanged unless you give written request.

In that case, you will continue for same duration, even with lower interest.

So, extra principal goes as prepayment or buffer, not as actual tenure cut.

To benefit fully, ask for a revised amortisation schedule.

That will confirm whether tenure is shortened or same.

If same, then request bank to reduce tenure officially.

This will ensure loan closure earlier and less total interest paid.

Interest Rate Dynamics: Small Reduction, Moderate Impact

Your interest rate drop is from 8.50% to 8.25%.

It is a 0.25% reduction only.

On Rs. 56 lakh loan, it saves some interest over time.

But the savings are not very large.

However, with higher EMI, these savings accumulate better.

Over 15 to 20 years, even 0.25% can save lakhs.

You must continue to monitor rate changes going forward.

Any further drop in repo rate must be checked with the lender.

Always keep your loan in floating interest rate structure.

This ensures automatic adjustment with repo-linked rates.

Interest Rate Review with Bank – Important Step

Visit your bank branch or call customer care.

Request latest interest rate applicable on your loan.

Ask for revised amortisation schedule with current rate.

See whether tenure has reduced automatically or not.

If not, ask them to recalculate with same EMI and reduced tenure.

This way, you gain full benefit of repo rate change.

Term Insurance in EMI – Things to Watch

You mentioned that your EMI includes term insurance.

Many banks give group term plans with home loans.

These are sometimes bundled into EMI amount.

You must review the terms of this cover.

Check if this is a one-time premium or annual charge.

See whether this term insurance covers only home loan or full life cover.

Also check if it is reducing cover or fixed cover.

You can also compare this with personal term plans bought separately.

A regular term insurance bought from MFD with CFP advice is often cheaper.

Explore Prepayment Opportunities

You are already showing financial awareness.

If possible, make small prepayments once or twice a year.

Even Rs. 50,000 per year prepayment can reduce your tenure by many months.

Prepayments early in loan term save the most interest.

Check whether your bank charges penalty on prepayment.

If not, use annual bonuses or surplus income for this.

Ensure all prepayments are recorded as principal reduction.

Ask bank for acknowledgement and revised schedule.

Avoid Real Estate as Investment

You are already repaying a home loan. That is your own property.

Do not take more loans to buy property as investment.

Real estate is illiquid and high-maintenance.

It also gives low rental yield. Capital appreciation is uncertain.

Instead of buying more property, invest in long-term financial instruments.

Build Emergency Fund and Continue SIPs

Keep emergency funds equal to at least 6 months EMI + 6 months expenses.

It should be in liquid funds or savings account.

Continue your mutual fund SIPs without break.

Avoid index funds. They just copy the market and lack professional fund manager strategy.

Actively managed funds by professional fund managers give better performance.

Choose regular plans with the help of MFD with CFP credentials.

Avoid direct plans. They look cheaper, but there is no personalised advice.

Wrong scheme selection in direct plans may hurt your long-term returns.

Avoid New Debts and Personal Loans

Avoid taking new personal loans or credit card EMIs.

They come with high interest rates.

Even small EMIs affect your home loan affordability.

Reduce liabilities and focus on wealth building.

LIC Policy Review – Suggestion to Reassess

If you hold traditional LIC endowment plans or ULIPs, review them closely.

These offer low returns, usually 4% to 5%.

Surrender such policies if they are investment cum insurance.

Reinvest maturity or surrender proceeds into mutual funds.

Take a pure term insurance separately.

Do this under the guidance of a Certified Financial Planner.

Long-Term Focus – Freedom from Loan

Your final goal should be to become loan-free by age 50 or earlier.

That gives you financial freedom and mental peace.

Plan all financial moves keeping this goal in mind.

Avoid lifestyle inflation or impulse spends.

Every extra rupee saved today will save more interest tomorrow.

Aim for financial discipline, not just financial products.

Finally

You are already managing the loan responsibly. That itself is great.

Keeping EMI same and letting tenure reduce works in your favour.

Confirm with bank about tenure reduction officially.

Avoid new loans and increase prepayments slowly.

Continue SIPs in regular funds through MFD and Certified Financial Planner.

Reassess old LIC investment plans if any.

Set your goal to be debt-free before retirement.

Financial planning is not only about returns. It is also about control.

You are on the right path. Just fine-tune your steps.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

..Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |8940 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 18, 2025

Money
Hello Sir I have a question that i have existing home loan of now rs 2900000 and 25 years of time has left rest i have paid , i am investing 1 lac per month in mutual funds and investing in gold as well shall i pay my laon first or keep.investing in mf and gold and keep paying emi plus extra amount in loan my loan roi is 8.80%
Ans: Your approach is sincere and responsible. Managing Rs. 29 lakh home loan while investing Rs. 1 lakh monthly needs clarity. You also invest in gold. Your focus seems on building wealth and becoming debt-free. Let’s assess your current situation from all angles and guide accordingly.

Understanding the Current Scenario
You have a home loan balance of Rs. 29 lakh.

Loan interest rate is 8.80%.

Loan tenure left is 25 years.

You are investing Rs. 1 lakh every month in mutual funds.

You are also buying gold regularly.

You are paying regular EMIs.

You are also thinking to prepay the home loan partially.

This situation is not uncommon. Many in your position face the same decision. Let us now break it down for better understanding.

Loan Repayment vs Investment: Core Conflict
Loan EMI gives guaranteed interest saving.

Mutual funds and gold have market risk. Returns are not fixed.

Loan rate is 8.80%. This is a high cost in long term.

Mutual funds can give 12% in long term. But no guarantee.

Gold can give 6-7% return over long term. Also not guaranteed.

So comparing loan vs MF or gold is not just about return.

Risk, liquidity, and financial goals must be seen together.

Evaluating Home Loan Repayment Strategy
Home loan gives tax benefit on interest under Sec 24(b).

But this benefit reduces over time as interest part reduces.

Long tenure increases total interest paid.

If you prepay loan now, you save high future interest.

Partial prepayment every year brings great interest saving.

Even Rs. 1 lakh prepayment per year can cut 4-5 years from loan term.

So prepayment makes sense if no other high priority goals pending.

Understanding Mutual Fund Investment Potential
You are investing Rs. 1 lakh monthly. That is commendable.

Mutual funds help build long term wealth.

Actively managed funds perform better than passive ones in India.

Index funds don’t beat inflation much after tax.

Active funds adjust to market cycles better.

Your SIP of Rs. 1 lakh may give strong corpus in 15-20 years.

Taxation on MF has changed now. Need to plan redemption smartly.

Short-term capital gains are taxed at 20%.

LTCG above Rs. 1.25 lakh is taxed at 12.5%.

Role of Gold in Portfolio
Gold acts as hedge in portfolio.

It protects against currency devaluation and global risk.

But gold alone should not be large part of investment.

It gives 6-7% return in long term.

It is not cash flow generating.

Use gold for diversification only. 10-15% is enough.

Assessing Your Loan Repayment Capacity
If you can spare extra Rs. 20-30K per month, loan prepayment makes sense.

Continue EMI as usual. Add lump sum when possible.

Avoid using your mutual fund SIP for prepayment.

Don’t stop gold purchase fully. Just reduce it if needed.

Balance your cash flow between all goals.

Combining Both: Smart Way Forward
You can do both prepayment and investments side by side.

Continue Rs. 1 lakh monthly in mutual funds.

From bonuses, windfalls, use part for home loan prepayment.

Avoid stopping SIP. It compounds over time.

Increase SIP by 5-10% yearly if income grows.

This way you build wealth and reduce debt slowly.

Tax Impact and Liquidity Planning
Prepaying home loan gives emotional peace.

But MF investments are liquid in emergencies.

Loan prepayment is not reversible.

Once paid, money is locked in property.

Keep emergency fund ready. 6 months expenses is good target.

Your Child and Family Needs
You have a child. Future education will need funds.

Mutual funds can fund child education and marriage.

Prepaying loan is less flexible than investing for child's future.

So don’t rush to be debt free if child goals are underfunded.

Cash Flow Planning for Better Balance
Track your monthly cash flow closely.

Prioritise emergency fund first.

After that, child education fund.

After that, home loan prepayment.

Avoid big gold purchases if loan EMI is tight.

Keep gold for portfolio balance only.

Emotional vs Logical Decision-Making
Loan-free life feels peaceful.

But wealth creation needs patience.

Don’t get swayed by fear of loan.

Instead, make clear plan.

Mix investment with prepayment.

What You Can Practically Do Now
Continue SIP of Rs. 1 lakh.

Build emergency fund equal to 6 months expense.

Invest at least Rs. 5-10K monthly for child education.

Reduce gold purchase to 10-15% of monthly investment.

Once emergency fund is ready, prepay Rs. 1-2 lakh per year in home loan.

Final Insights
Your loan is at 8.80%.

Mutual funds can beat this in long term.

But loan is risk-free return.

Emotional peace matters too.

Balance both wisely.

Stay consistent.

Do yearly review of all investments.

Increase SIP and loan prepayment step-by-step as income grows.

Avoid random investment decisions.

Be goal-based always.

Invest through certified professionals who guide with long-term vision.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

..Read more

Latest Questions
Ravi

Ravi Mittal  |602 Answers  |Ask -

Dating, Relationships Expert - Answered on Jun 19, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Jun 19, 2025
Relationship
Why do men ghost after sex? I met this amazing guy on Hinge. He was 27, well-mannered, and worked in a data firm in Mumbai. We spoke daily for three months and had amazing chemistry. From music to food, we discussed everything under the sun. We went on a couple of dates to get to know each other. When we got comfortable, we got intimate and eventually had consensual s** at his friend's house party. One week after we got intimate, he just vanished. No replies, no calls. It was my first time, so I kept wondering if I had done something wrong to upset him. My friend says it could be post-intimacy guilt. But I feel embarrassed, ashamed. I can't shake off the shame. Did I move too fast? Is this how dating works now? How can I go back to feeling normal again?
Ans: Dear Anonymous,
I am really sorry you are going through this. What happened is just as confusing as it is hurtful. Let’s get one thing straight, you did nothing wrong. You are not at fault here. Nothing you could’ve done or said should or could cause this reaction.
Coming to your first question, it is very difficult to answer it without generalizing all men. But some of the most reasons for this could be:
He got what he wanted. It sounds crass but in most cases, this is the truth. He had no intentions of being more than just that.
He might be avoiding responsibility. He didn’t want more, and the mature thing would have been to sit down and have that discussion with you. But, maturity isn’t easy and he chose the easy route, that is to ghost. His decision to disappear is a reflection of his nature, not yours.
Coming to what your friend said, it could be that too, but the chances are slim. Some men do feel overwhelmed but disappearing for over a week is a stretch. Again, it’s his unreadiness to feel so many emotions, not yours.
Now, I want to gently nudge you towards one thing: you said you feel ashamed. Shame creeps in when you hold yourself accountable for someone else’s actions. And also due to societal prejudice. Keep both aside, and you have nothing to be ashamed of. Did you move too fast? To be honest, there is no fast or slow in these things. There’s no set timeline. You did what you felt was right in the moment. And you were ready to step up, but he went MIA. The entire unfortunate turnout is not because of your pace but his lack of respect. Even if he comes up with a good enough reason for this disappearing act, I still want you to remember that not even for a second, you had anything to create this situation.


I hope this helps.

...Read more

DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Investment in securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related document carefully before investing. The securities quoted are for illustration only and are not recommendatory. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information and as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision. RediffGURUS is an intermediary as per India's Information Technology Act.

Close  

You haven't logged in yet. To ask a question, Please Log in below
Login

A verification OTP will be sent to this
Mobile Number / Email

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to

Resend OTP in120seconds

Dear User, You have not registered yet. Please register by filling the fields below to get expert answers from our Gurus
Sign up

By signing up, you agree to our
Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy

Already have an account?

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to Mobile

Resend OTP in120seconds

x