I have annual expenses like tem insurance premium, medical insurance premium, nps contribution, annual holiday travels, baby school fee etc which is around 468000 per annum requirement but due falls on different intervals so need to park this annual requirement from monthly savings around 40k per month . RD or liquid funds if liquid funds which is good or FD or debt funds if so which debt funds.. I fall under 30percent tax slab.. so suggest which mode is good
Ans: You have done very well by planning for your annual expenses in advance. Most people miss this important step. You have also identified the yearly requirement and your monthly saving capacity. This shows good financial discipline. Let me give you a 360-degree perspective on how you can manage these periodic expenses better.
» Nature of Your Annual Expenses
– Your expenses like term insurance premium, medical premium, NPS contribution, travel, and school fees are fixed in nature.
– These expenses are unavoidable and need liquidity at specific intervals.
– Safety of funds is important because these are non-negotiable commitments.
– Tax efficiency is also important because you are in the 30% tax slab.
– Therefore, your investment vehicle should provide liquidity, safety, and some growth.
» Why Not Use Regular Bank Savings
– Many people keep such money in savings account.
– Savings account earns low interest.
– After tax, returns are even lower.
– Inflation further reduces value of such idle money.
– Hence, keeping entire Rs.40,000 every month in savings account is not efficient.
» Recurring Deposits (RD)
– RD is simple to operate.
– You can commit Rs.40,000 per month easily.
– Interest is fixed and predictable.
– But interest is taxed fully as per slab.
– In your case, 30% tax reduces net return significantly.
– Liquidity is limited. Premature withdrawal leads to penalty.
– RD is safe but not tax efficient.
» Fixed Deposits (FD)
– FD gives fixed interest.
– It is stable and safe.
– But interest is fully taxable like RD.
– Premature withdrawal leads to penalty.
– Not suitable for regular liquidity needs.
– FD works better for lump sum parking, not monthly parking.
» Liquid Funds
– Liquid funds invest in very short-term money market instruments.
– They provide good liquidity. Redemption happens in one day.
– Returns are slightly higher than savings account and sometimes higher than RD post-tax.
– These funds are relatively safe as they avoid long duration risk.
– But they are not fully tax efficient for you. Gains are taxed as per slab since these are debt funds.
– Still, liquid funds are convenient for monthly parking and periodic withdrawals.
» Ultra Short-Term Debt Funds
– These funds invest in slightly longer maturity instruments than liquid funds.
– They provide better returns than liquid funds in most cases.
– They carry low interest rate risk.
– Liquidity is good, redemption in one day.
– They are taxed as per income slab if gains realised.
– For annual expense management, these can be more rewarding than RD and FD.
– Risk is slightly higher than liquid funds but still manageable.
» Arbitrage Funds
– Arbitrage funds invest in equity and derivatives.
– They are treated as equity for taxation.
– This means after one year, gains above Rs.1.25 lakh are taxed at 12.5%.
– But for short term (less than one year), gains are taxed at 20%.
– These funds provide returns close to liquid funds.
– Volatility is low compared to pure equity.
– Suitable for high tax bracket investors like you.
– But for annual expenses, time horizon is less than one year. So, taxation benefit reduces.
» Comparing Options Objectively
– Savings account: very low return, very liquid.
– RD: predictable return, taxed at 30%, liquidity low.
– FD: predictable return, taxed at 30%, liquidity low.
– Liquid funds: better post-tax return, high liquidity, manageable risk.
– Ultra-short term funds: slightly higher return, similar liquidity, manageable risk.
– Arbitrage funds: good for long horizon, but for annual expense planning, not very efficient.
» Tax Angle for You
– You are in 30% tax slab.
– RD and FD returns are fully taxable.
– Debt funds also taxed as per slab for short term.
– But debt funds offer some flexibility in timing redemption.
– Liquid and ultra-short funds are still better because you can redeem only when required.
– This reduces tax outgo compared to RD where tax applies yearly irrespective of withdrawal.
» Practical Execution Plan
– You need Rs.4.68 lakh per year.
– You save Rs.40,000 every month.
– Best way is to set up a Systematic Investment Plan (SIP) in liquid or ultra-short term debt funds.
– This way, money is parked every month automatically.
– When expenses arise, you can redeem only that much.
– Rest of the money continues to earn return.
– This makes it flexible and efficient.
» Behavioural Benefits
– With RD or FD, once maturity comes, all money comes together.
– There is a chance of spending extra.
– With liquid or debt funds, you redeem only required amount.
– This helps in disciplined spending.
– Also avoids locking in money unnecessarily.
» Why Not Index Funds or ETFs
– Some investors confuse these products for short-term parking.
– But index funds and ETFs are equity-oriented.
– They are volatile in short term.
– For annual commitments, volatility is dangerous.
– Index funds may fall 10% in one month.
– That will disturb your annual expense plan.
– Actively managed debt funds or liquid funds are far safer for your goal.
» Why Not Direct Mutual Funds for You
– Many think direct funds give higher return by saving distributor fee.
– But investment discipline and product selection is key.
– Investing through a Certified Financial Planner and MFD gives guidance.
– They help you align funds with goals.
– Mistakes in direct funds may cost more than saved fee.
– Regular plan with CFP-backed MFD gives you personalised handholding.
– For someone with family responsibilities and annual commitments, guidance matters more.
» Risk Management
– Even liquid and debt funds carry small risks.
– But risk is far lower than equity.
– Choose funds with strong track record.
– Diversify across 2-3 funds.
– Review once in six months with your planner.
– This keeps your annual expense plan safe and smooth.
» Integration with Your Overall Financial Plan
– These annual expenses are part of your cash flow management.
– They should not be mixed with long term goals.
– Keep these liquid and debt fund investments separate.
– Long term goals like retirement, children’s education need separate equity allocation.
– This separation of buckets will give clarity.
– You will avoid using long-term money for short-term needs.
» Psychological Peace
– Knowing your annual expenses are already funded gives peace of mind.
– You will enjoy travel without worrying about money.
– You will pay school fee on time without stress.
– Insurance premiums will not disturb your monthly budget.
– This builds confidence in your financial journey.
» Steps You Can Take Immediately
– Decide to channel Rs.40,000 monthly in a liquid or ultra-short term debt fund.
– Mark each investment as “Annual Expenses Fund.”
– Keep a schedule of due dates of all expenses.
– One week before due date, redeem required amount.
– Keep records of withdrawals for clarity.
– At year end, review with your Certified Financial Planner.
» Finally
– You are already disciplined in savings. That itself is a big achievement.
– Your goal is not wealth creation here, but smooth liquidity.
– RD and FD will eat away your return due to taxation.
– Liquid or ultra-short term debt funds will suit you better.
– These will give you liquidity, safety, and efficiency.
– Stay consistent with this approach. Over years, you will see the benefits.
– Always review with your Certified Financial Planner for best alignment.
Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment